Bill, Frank, Cathy, Dolly and Jill read three of
the following books last summer:
The Hobbit, Speak, The Lorax,
To Kill a Mockingbird, and Little Women.
To solve this puzzle, create a table below with Y
representing the books read, and X representing the books not read.
Bill and Frank did not read
Little Women.
Cathy did not read The Hobbit.
Based on the above we have
|
Hobbit |
Speak |
Lorax |
Mockingbird |
Little Women |
Bill |
|
|
|
|
X |
Frank |
|
|
|
|
X |
Cathy |
X |
|
|
|
|
Dolly |
|
|
|
|
|
Jill |
|
|
|
|
|
Dolly was the only one who read The
Lorax.
|
Hobbit |
Speak |
Lorax |
Mockingbird |
Little Women |
Bill |
|
|
X |
|
X |
Frank |
|
|
X |
|
X |
Cathy |
X |
|
X |
|
|
Dolly |
|
|
Y |
|
|
Jill |
|
|
X |
|
|
Since we know the two books
Bill, Frank, and Cathy did not read, we know the three books each of them read.
|
Hobbit |
Speak |
Lorax |
Mockingbird |
Little Women |
Bill |
Y |
Y |
X |
Y |
X |
Frank |
Y |
Y |
X |
Y |
X |
Cathy |
X |
Y |
X |
Y |
Y |
Dolly |
|
|
Y |
|
|
Jill |
|
|
X |
|
|
Three of them read To Kill a
Mokingbird,
|
Hobbit |
Speak |
Lorax |
Mockingbird |
Little Women |
Bill |
Y |
Y |
X |
Y |
X |
Frank |
Y |
Y |
X |
Y |
X |
Cathy |
X |
Y |
X |
Y |
Y |
Dolly |
|
|
Y |
X |
|
Jill |
|
|
X |
X |
|
Thus, we know the three books Jill read.
|
Hobbit |
Speak |
Lorax |
Mockingbird |
Little Women |
Bill |
Y |
Y |
X |
Y |
X |
Frank |
Y |
Y |
X |
Y |
X |
Cathy |
X |
Y |
X |
Y |
Y |
Dolly |
|
|
Y |
X |
|
Jill |
Y |
Y |
X |
X |
Y |
Three of them read The Hobbit, this
results in
|
Hobbit |
Speak |
Lorax |
Mockingbird |
Little Women |
Bill |
Y |
Y |
X |
Y |
X |
Frank |
Y |
Y |
X |
Y |
X |
Cathy |
X |
Y |
X |
Y |
Y |
Dolly |
X |
Y |
Y |
X |
Y |
Jill |
Y |
Y |
X |
X |
Y |
From the table above, we conclude that
Bill read The Hobbit, Speak, and
To Kill a Mockingbird.
Frank read The Hobbit, Speak, and
To Kill a Mockingbird.
Cathy read Speak, To Kill a
Mockingbird, and Little Women.
Dolly read Speak, The Lorax,
and Little Women.
Jill read The Hobbit, Speak,
and Little Women.
|